Advertise Here
Icon

Directory

IconActuaries
IconAssociations & Institutes
IconAuditors
IconBBBEE Consulting and Verification Agencies
IconBenefit Administrators & Investment Managers
IconBusiness Chambers
IconBusiness Process Management
IconBusiness Process Outsourcing
IconCompliance
IconConsumer Protection
IconCorporate Governance
IconCredit Bureaus
IconDebit Order Collection Facilities
IconEducation and Training
IconFAIS
IconHuman Resources
IconInformation Technology and Software Partners
IconLegal
IconOmbud
IconPension Fund Trustee Liability Insurance
IconPension Fund Trustee Training
IconPension Funds Adjudicator
IconPolicy Administration
IconPolicy Trading
IconPublications
IconRegulatory Authorities
IconRetirement Funds registered by the FSB
IconRetirement Products
IconSocial Grants (Government)
IconSurveys and Research
IconTraining Courses & Workshops
IconTrust Establishment & Management
IconWellness Programs
Image
  Subscribe To »

The Pandemic, Physical Damage, Business Interruption Losses and Reinsurance

Published

2020

Tue

07

Apr

 

The Pandemic, Physical Damage, Business Interruption Losses and Reinsurance

How is your 2000 piece jigsaw puzzle progressing? 

 

Coronavirus and physical damage

You may have seen reference to the recent Ontario Superior Court of Justice decision in MDS Inc v Factory Mutual Insurance Company (FM Global) (2020) ONSC 1924.  A copy of the judgment is attached.

The judgment has been punted as “significantly increasing the possibility of coverage for business interruption arising from Covid-19”.   

The judgment needs to be approached with significant caution.  It is of course a Canadian judgment and only persuasive and not binding on South African courts. 

It dealt, inter alia with what constitutes “physical damage” in the context of an all-risks property insurance policy.  In the context the insurer unsuccessfully argued that the mere loss of use of the premises did not give rise to physical damage, insisting that there must be “tangible” property damage.

 

Asides from not being South African authority on the point, the judgment is distinguishable for various reasons.  The case dealt with an all-risks property insurance policy.  The traditional South African business interruption section wording is not all-risks. It requires damages defined emanating usually from the fire perils listed under the fire section of the policy.  The case also turned on the wording of the exception raised by the insurer and on which the insurer bore the onus. It was accepted that on the all-risks basis but for application of the exception the policy would be required to respond.

 

It is for the insured to bring themselves into the four corners of the business interruption section of the policy and discharge the onus on the probabilities in that regard.

The case also arose in a different context, the proactive shutdown, for safety reasons of a nuclear facility that was not actually damaged but in respect of which there was actually the presence of leaking heavy water.  In most cases there is unlikely to be the actual presence of  coronavirus or a coronavirus positive person upon the insured premises.

Of course in each case the specific wording of the policy needs to be considered on the facts. Whether loss of use is damage in the context remains unlikely.

 

The judgment is a lengthy one.

When you have finished your 2000 piece puzzle and have nothing else to do  it is worth a read in particular the consideration of the case law examples given regarding damage and physical damage. 

 

Reinsurance

 

In the anticipation of Coronavirus claims and the determination of your policy responses, your reinsurance coverage should not be forgotten.  Is there reinsurance cover back-to-back?  And what is the claim settlement authority?

 

Is the cover follow the fortunes or follow the settlements?

The risk is of course where an insurer agrees to settle claims without being able to establish that on the balance of probabilities it has a legal liability to do  there may well be a challenge to collecting such settlements from reinsurers.

For example of a full follow the settlement clause see Insurance Company of Africa v Scor [1985] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 312. For an exception example, see Wasa v Lexington, [2009] UK HL 40.

Also consider the effects of any “double proviso” follow clause.  See for example Hill v M&G [1996] 1 WLR 1239.  The double proviso clause usually requires a cedent to prove that the loss falls within the terms of both the original and the reinsurance contract.  It may not be sufficient for the purpose of that clause to rely on the advice of a lawyer . In Commercial Union Assurance Company PLC. v NRG Victory Reinsurance Ltd [1998] 2 Lloyd’s Rep. 600 the court said that the question whether it was arguable that the  reinsurer might be not liable to the reinsureds was for the Court to decide.

 


  Downloads »

TypeSize
MDS Inc v Factory Mutual Insurance Company (FM Global) (2020) ONSC 1924
IconPDF
5 MB
 
Source: Donald Dinnie - Norton Rose Fulbright South Africa Inc
 
« Back to previous page Print this page » |
 

Breaking News »

Insurance and Risk in a Post-Covid Economy

Certain insurance classes will take a hit while others will have time to recover, consumer behaviour will radically change the rules of engagement for insurers and brokers, and accelerate digital transformation   Nothing ...
Read More »

  

COVID-19 Swings the Spotlight Back onto Emerging Countries’ Debt

While the focus so far has been mainly on China, Europe and the United States, the consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic are likely to be even more severe for emerging economies, says International credit insurer, ...
Read More »

  

Coronavirus impact on shipping industry: idle vessels face new risks, Allianz warns

Increasing disruption and economic pressures caused by the pandemic also has serious risk management implications for the maritime community and insurers alike. Covid-19 pandemic makes it difficult to relieve crews, ...
Read More »

  

Coronavirus: Fighting the rise in cyber criminals from the home office

With many people working remotely because of the coronavirus outbreak, the number of cyber incidents is increasing as hackers, scammers and spammers look to exploit vulnerabilities in an attempt to steal valuable ...
Read More »

 

More News »

Image

Healthcare »

Image

Investment »

Image

Life »

Image

Short-term »

Advertise Here
Image
Image
Advertise Here

From The Glossary »

Icon

Householders Insurance:

This covers loss or damage in respect of domestic contents. house owners insurance This covers loss or damage to the home of the insured from a variety of perils, essentially fire and allied perils.
More Definitions »

 

Advertise

 

eZine

 

Contact IG

 

Media Pack

 

RSS Feeds

By using this website you agree to the Terms of Use.
Copyright © Insurance Gateway (Pty) Ltd 2004 - 2020. All Rights Reserved.