Image
Icon

Directory

IconAppraisers and Valuers
IconAssociations and Institutes
IconBBBEE Consulting and Verification Agencies
IconConsumer Protection
IconCorporate Governance
IconCredit Bureaus
IconDefensive Driver Training
IconEmergency Medical Rescue
IconForensic Investigation Services
IconInsurance Brokers - Alphabetical Listing
IconInsurance Brokers by Type of Product or Service Needed
IconInsurance Companies
IconInsurance Consultants
IconLightning Damage & Surge Protection Specialists
IconOmbud
IconOnline Quotes and Cover
IconPremium Financing
IconPublic Loss Adjustors
IconPublications
IconRating Agencies
IconRegulatory Authorities
IconRisk Finance
IconRisk Management
IconRisk Surveyors
IconSalvage Operators
IconTelephone Quotes
IconVehicle Accident Management
IconVehicle and Household Risk Inspection Services
IconVehicle Tracking
IconWellness Programs
Advertise Here
  Subscribe To »

When does a claim under a liability policy prescribe?

Published

2019

Thu

12

Dec

 

A claim for indemnification under a liability insurance contract only arises when liability to a third party for a certain amount has been established. For purposes of prescription, the debt becomes due when the insured is under legal liability to pay a fixed and determined sum of money. Until then a ‘claim’ for indemnification under the policy doesn’t exist and cannot prescribe.

The insured in Magic Eye Trading 77 CC v Santam Limited had been sued by a third party for damage to his vehicle allegedly as a result of the negligent conduct of the insured’s employee. The insured joined the insurer to the proceedings as a third party based on their insurance policy which included indemnity insurance against loss suffered by the insured by way of liability to third parties. The insurer alleged that the claim for indemnity had prescribed, alleging that upon the occurrence of the defined event, or when the insured and its employee became aware of the event, or when the insurer rejected the claim, the right to indemnity against the contingent future monetary consequences of the accident became vested in the insured. And because the insured hadn’t instituted proceedings within three years of any of those events the claim had allegedly prescribed.

The courts stressed the distinction between a claim and a contingent claim. An insured is only entitled to indemnity against loss or damage when they become legally liable to a third party. An insured can only become legally liable to pay once that sum due by them is fixed by a court or by agreement. Until then no claim for indemnification can arise.

The corollary also applies. In the event of a rejection of liability by the insurer requiring institution of any action within a certain period after the rejection, that condition doesn’t permit the general rejection of future claims at a stage when a precise claim in a fixed amount is not and cannot be made by the insured.

In the circumstances the insurer could not rely on the statutory prescription period, nor any time bar provisions in the policy.

The position is different where first party insurance is concerned. In the normal course of events, whether it be a life or non-life insurance policy, the debt owed by the insurer becomes due as soon as the event insured against has taken place. In the case of life insurance for example the debt is due on the death of the life insured. Prescription commences to run against the beneficiary if at that stage the existence of the policy, the identity of the insurer, their nomination as beneficiary and the death of the deceased are known to the beneficiary. The beneficiary doesn’t have to wait for the insurer’s decision whether to pay or not and any delay by the insurer in making a decision doesn’t delay the commencement of prescription. See for example Danielz NO v De Wet and Van der Westhuizen v Hollard Life. The same principle applies where for example the insured claims for theft of a motor vehicle or damage or destruction of the insured property by fire. Prescription starts running when the loss event occurs.

Prescription can be interrupted by service on the insurer of a summons or by an express or tacit acknowledgement of liability on the part of the insurer.

Also bear in mind that in terms of the Ombud Rules and the Policyholder Protection Rules the running of prescription or time bar provisions will be interrupted or suspended in certain circumstances.

The Supreme Court of Appeal in Magic Eye Trading 77 CC v Santam Limited dealt authoritatively with the question of when a contingent right to claim an indemnity prescribes. The principles are not new but the judgment contains a useful review and discussion of the relevant case law.

 
Source: Donald Dinnie Director Norton Rose Fulbright South Africa Inc
 
« Back to previous page Print this page » |
 

Breaking News »

Coronavirus: Loss prevention measures for cargo storage and transportation

The pandemic has brought about sudden changes for cargo transportation, impacting shippers and transport companies around the world and potentially increasing the risk environment, particularly for high-value ...
Read More »

  

Coronavirus: Safeguarding Of Construction Sites During A Cessation Of Works

Many construction sites face the prospect of having to temporarily shut down as the coronavirus outbreak brings a halt to operations. In a new risk bulletin, Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty’s risk ...
Read More »

  

The Pandemic, Physical Damage, Business Interruption Losses and Reinsurance

The Pandemic, Physical Damage, Business Interruption Losses and Reinsurance How is your 2000 piece jigsaw puzzle progressing?   Coronavirus and physical damage You may have seen reference ...
Read More »

  

Savvy ways to save on insurance and utility costs by managing your risks better

With the economy taking a hammering and sharp price increases on everything from petrol, food and basic commodities like water and electricity, there is no more crucial time to take the bull by the horns and save ...
Read More »

 

More News »

Image

Healthcare »

Image

Investment »

Image

Life »

Image

Retirement »

Advertise Here
Image
Image
Image
Advertise Here

From The Glossary »

Icon

Past Service Benefit:

Credit given to an employee for past service with an employer prior to joining a pension scheme.
More Definitions »

 

Advertise

 

eZine

 

Contact IG

 

Media Pack

 

RSS Feeds

By using this website you agree to the Terms of Use.
Copyright © Insurance Gateway (Pty) Ltd 2004 - 2020. All Rights Reserved.